2020: Zoom In
The essay that fixed the word in its current sense is Zoom In: An Introduction to
Circuits, which opens the Distill Circuits thread.
Its framing is the microscope: several turning points in science were moments when a new
instrument let people see one level further down, and a new field grew around what they saw.
The claim is that the trained weights of a vision model can be studied the same way, neuron by
neuron and connection by connection, and that this is a natural science rather than a
mathematics.
The authors make their bet explicit by putting it next to an older one. In 1839 Theodor Schwann
stated three claims about cells; two of them survive as cell theory and the third turned out to
be wrong. They then offer three claims of their own in the same spirit, "articulating a strong
version of something one may believe to be true, even if it might be false".
Schwann's Claims about Cells
Theodor Schwann, 1839, as summarised in Zoom In
- Claim 1. The cell is the unit of structure, physiology, and organization in living things.
- Claim 2. The cell retains a dual existence as a distinct entity and a building block in the construction of organisms.
- Claim 3. Cells form by free-cell formation, similar to the formation of crystals.
The first two persist in modern cell theory. The third, as the essay puts it, "turned out to be horribly wrong".
Three Speculative Claims about Neural Networks
Olah, Cammarata, Schubert, Goh, Petrov, Carter, 2020
- Claim 1: Features. Features are the fundamental unit of neural networks. They correspond to directions. These features can be rigorously studied and understood.
- Claim 2: Circuits. Features are connected by weights, forming circuits. These circuits can also be rigorously studied and understood.
- Claim 3: Universality. Analogous features and circuits form across models and tasks.
Stated as both empirical claims about networks and normative claims about how it is useful to understand them.
Both lists are quoted from Olah, C., Cammarata, N., Schubert, L., Goh, G., Petrov, M., Carter, S. (2020).
Zoom In: An Introduction to Circuits. Distill.
doi:10.23915/distill.00024.001. Text licensed CC-BY 4.0.
The second claim is the definition this page is about. In Zoom In a circuit is "a
computational subgraph of a neural network": a set of features and the weighted edges between
them, usually small, studied by looking at the weights directly. The examples are curve
detectors, a dog-head detector assembled from oriented parts, and a car detector that shares its
neurons with other things. What the poster does five years later on a language model is the
same move with different instruments.